Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Torturers must be punished

Ruth Marcus’ column in the Post on Wednesday, 31 December, arguing against torture trials attempts to minimize the crime, in a number of incredible ways.

1. She suggests that the threat of internal investigations or Congressional hearings would be effective deterrents. This would be laughable, if the subject were not so serious. The threat of criminal convictions and serious jail time is what is needed to deter those who would torture in the name of patriotism. Remember, this is a crime under both U.S. and international law. It is a crime against humanity. It is inexcusable for anyone, anywhere, to impose torture upon another. Indeed, the threat of punishment needs to be so strong and so credible, that those so inclined would fearfully resist the impulse. An internal investigation? A Congressional hearing? Not threats at all, as experienced under the Bush administration.

2. She suggests that the threat of criminal sanctions did not deter Bush officials anyway. Right: it is actual swift convictions and sentences which would provide the deterrent, not the possibility of someday facing the consequences.

3. She suggests stronger oversight to prevent torture. This is both after the fact and too late, and lacking in penalty: what would the oversight group do, but perhaps censure the torturers? Again, this is not enough.

4. She suggests that the costs of criminal prosecutions would be too high, and that officials could err on the side of excessive timidity. Given the choice between a tortured victim and a timid official, give me the timid official every time. There are some lines which should never be crossed. Torture is one such line.

5. She suggests that criminal prosecutions would drain energy from the new administration. Rather, I believe that the new administration is capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time; it can pursue revitalizing the economy, undoing the legislative and executive excesses of the Bush administration, and presecuting torturers. In fact, it must do this, to restore America’s moral standing with the world.

6. Finally, she raises the bar to “conscious law-breaking.” This is not necessary. Someone who tortures another, relying upon orders, or legal memos, still is guilty. It is time to remember the Nuremburg principles, and seek justice for those who would throw out the law and morality in pursuing their agendas.

Torture is a crime against humanity. In the name of humanity, it must be punished by criminal trial.

A radical fix for housing and the economy

It is time to go further than the current discussion and programs to help America's home owners in a meaningful way. Here is one idea, which would cost the public nothing, and put money into people's pockets for years to come.

We need federal legislation to reset every primary home mortgage in the country to a 4 1/2 % interest rate for the balance of the loans.

This would apply to current long-term mortgages, and convert every adjustable rate mortgage to a 30-year term fixed rate. Lenders would have to redo the mortgage papers at no cost to the borrowers.

In addition, no new adjustable rate mortgages would be allowed, and all new mortgages for the next two years, at least, would be at the same 4 1/2 % 30 year interest rate.

Thus, the industry which created the mess would have to absorb some losses of income, but the home owners would have lower monthly payments, and a better chance of staying in their homes. Foreclosures would be much less likely. The housing sector would be stabilized, at last.

Saturday, November 8, 2008

Screening Agency Leaders

The transition to a new administration requires a close look at agency Senior Executives, many of whom already are flooding the transition team with endorsements from interest groups.

In addition to the usual reference checks, here are two suggestions for the transition team:

1. Ask the agency staff for input on managers’ leadership skills: (1) can they manage projects and people effectively; (2) do they support their staff; (3) are they innovative; and (4) are they fair. These few questions will expose both talents and faults rapidly.

2. Reject the conventional wisdom about how hard it is to remove poor managers. The Civil Service Reform Act of 1978, which created the Senior Executive Service, gave the administration the tool: after the 120 day transition period, Senior Executives can be asked to relocate geographically, with two weeks’ notice. If they refuse, they have to leave the service, and revert to a lower GS position. A select number of such actions would send a powerful message to all executives.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Hot buttons

In the last stretch of the campaign, Mr. McCain and his friends have been reaching for long discredited hot button slogans to energize his base. Just as his prior efforts to sling mud have not worked well, it appears that this new and desperate attack will fall short.

Still, one should note some of the problems with his language.

“Redistributing the wealth” is a bad thing, and sounds like “socialism.” Well, Mr. McCain, a progressive income tax has been part of our system for a really long time. You might even remember when it was established. At one time, the marginal tax rate on the very rich was 90%. More recently it was at 50% before reforms brought it down below 40%.

And why is progressivity reasonable? Our social compact and sense of mutual responsibility calls for those who can afford it to pay proportionately more than those who cannot. Do you really think that if multimillionaires paid a few hundred thousand dollars more in taxes, they would stop investing and trying to make more money? I doubt it. No, I suspect that you just are continuing the Republican tradition of trying to make the rich richer, at the expense of everyone else.

Extending the Bush tax cuts rewards the rich and punishes the rest of us. Is this how you fight for the regular guy?

Government itself is a mechanism for redistributing the wealth. We take income and reallocate it to national priorities, like defense, infrastructure, food safety, environmental protection and the like. Are you really a closet anarchist who wants no taxes and everyone on their own? If not, what level of taxes would be your bottom line? When would you stop cutting taxes? Would you limit the national government to the common defense and nothing else? If not, what else?

As for socialism, you certainly are aware of the Veteran’s hospital system. This is a government funded health care system, which competes with the private sector. One could call it socialism for the military. If you were consistent, shouldn’t you call for the abolition of this system? Will you? I doubt it.

In addition, isn’t the recent bail out of the financial system a socialist act? Getting the government into the heart of the business world? As one who believes in deregulation and the self-correcting nature of the free market system, shouldn’t you be calling to let the chips fall where they may, even if banks and companies go bankrupt in the process? The market will respond to consumer demand, even as individual companies fail, right?

As for Joe the plumber, whose name is not Joe and who is not a plumber, why do you continue the lie about Mr. Obama’s tax cuts, which you call a tax increase? If you simply say that meeting all his promises will require a tax increase, doesn’t this argument apply to you, too? Or, will you continue the Bush policy of spending money now by borrowing from the future, asking current voters to pay nothing more? Is this a responsible act, mortgaging our future, and burdening our children and grandchildren?

Enough. I’d respect the old McCain, who opposed the Bush tax cuts and supported some semblance of sound immigration policy. But that man has been eaten by the radical right of the Republican party. R.I.P.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Starting from the bottom

The right way to begin to deal with the Wall Street financial crisis is from the bottom: protecting the people who took out those adjustable mortgages and complex products which offered no interest loans, and other "free lunch" incentives.

The first step should be a nationwide freeze on foreclosures and interest rate "resets." People who could make mortgage payments at low interest rates could keep on making their payments. This freeze should be indefinite, while we sort out the complexities of the global situation. The at-risk mortgages would hold their value, rather than turn into foreclosure liabilities.

The second step is to resist the call to bail out the Wall Street firms who took unnecessary risks. If public funds are to help stabilize Wall Street, then the government should take over entire companies, restructure them, then resell them, rather than buying only their bad debts.

This is a beginning: the principle is people first, not the companies who brought about the crisis.

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Questions for McCain

Mr. McCain, you supported the war in Iraq because you, like many others, thought that we were in imminent danger from Saddam Hussein and his weapons of mass destruction. Well, he is gone, and there were no weapons of mass destruction. Are we still in imminent danger from Iraq? If not, what is our basis for staying there?

It is nice to want a stable democratic Iraq. Under international law, do we have a right to impose this on Iraqi citizens by force? How can tens of thousands of Iraqi dead and many more wounded be justified?How can thousands of American military dead and wounded be justified?

We know that Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11. We know that Iraq is not the headquarters of Al Qaeda. The fight against terrorism is elsewhere: why do you want to continue this illegal and wrong-headed war?

Two words to worry by

The words are "Adlai Stevenson." Intelligent, qualified, courageous, and a loser to a simple military man. What is needed is a comfort with jokes, an emotional capacity for outrage, and a willingness to use punch lines and sound bites, rather than nuance. Be a fighter, don't say you are a fighter. People want a personal connection, beyond eloquence.

Attack radical Republicanism, rather than Bush, since McCain is running against Bush, too.

Radical Republicanism squandered a budget surplus, and created huge new debts, passing on the costs of war and tax cuts to our children.

Radical Republicanism shredded the Constitution, tortured people, spied on Americans, claimed executive privilege to hide its misbehavior, cancelled treaties and waged illegal wars.

Radical Republicanism stomped on state rights, whenever states tried to do more than the federal level on business regulation and the environment.

Radical Republicanism wants to regulate the bedroom, but not the boardroom.

Radical Republicanism strives to make the world safe for business, while making it more dangerous for Americans.

Radical Republicanism deregulates, then bails out big businesses as too big to let fail. OK, let's go back to another time, and break up the oligopolies. Then, they won't be too big to fail. The public has paid for the risks, while the private has pocketed the profits. This has to stop.

Radical Republicanism favors the super rich over everyone else, forgetting the American Dream of egalitarianism.

McCain has contradicted his maverick positions to satisfy his base. McCain is a radical Republican. Palin is even more radical, and out of step with main street America.

This election IS about change. Change from Radical Republicanism back to main street values. Back to common purpose. Back to shared sacrifice. Back to the democratic ideal. Back to a government that serves the people. This is what Mr. Obama should be shouting about!